Sig P228 vs P229: Side-by-Side Comparison Review

In the world of firearms, no two models reign supreme in the compact handguns category as the Sig Sauer P228 and P229. Renowned for their superb design, remarkable durability, and exceptional performance, the P228 and P229 are weapons of choice for many law enforcement agencies and civilian gun enthusiasts worldwide. Comparing these two impressive firearm models may indeed be like splitting hairs, but for the discerning consumer, the distinctions might just be what tilts the scale. Let’s delve deeper into these two acclaimed handguns, examining their key features, pros, cons, and individual user experiences.

Comparison table: P228 vs. P229

The Sig Sauer P228

The P228, widely known as the M11 in the United States Military, is a compact, high-capacity semi-automatic handgun. While it’s no longer in production, the P228 holds a special place among firearm enthusiasts for its excellent balance, reliable operation, and easy concealability.

Key features of the P228

Caliber: The P228 is chambered in the globally recognized 9mm Parabellum.
Capacity: With a standard magazine capacity of 13 rounds, plus one in the chamber, the P228 boasts substantial firepower for its size.
Materials and Durability: Designed with a forged carbon steel slide and an alloy frame, the P228 showcases outstanding durability.

Personal Experience With the P228

From my personal perspective, operating the P228 has always been an enjoyable experience. Its compact design offers an unparalleled carry-comfort and easy concealability, making it a perfect companion for any defensive or recreational shooting scenario. Moreover, the handgun’s 9mm chambering provides a powerful yet manageable recoil, boosting reliability and accuracy. Despite being a second-hand owner, my P228 still performed remarkably well, displaying superior durability and dependability.

However, the main challenge I encountered with the P228 is that it is no longer in production. Finding accessories and parts like extra magazines, replacement sights, and grips can be somewhat difficult.

The Pros and Cons of the P228

Pros:
- Excellent balance and high capacity for its size.
- Easy to carry and conceal, ideal for self-defense.
- Promotes accuracy with its moderate recoil.
- Incredible durability and performance.
Cons:
- No longer in production, making it hard to source spare parts.
- Not as versatile in ammo types in comparison to the P229.

The Sig Sauer P229

Often deemed as the “big brother” of the P228, the P229 is an extensive evolution of the P-series lineage, showcasing greater versatility in its caliber options. The P229’s stainless steel slide makes the handgun better suited to handle the higher pressures from .40 S&W and .357 SIG cartridges.

Key Features of the P229

Caliber: Unlike its predecessor, the P229 is chambered in different calibers: .40 S&W, .357 SIG, and 9mm Parabellum.

Capacity: The capacity of the P229 depends on the caliber: 12 rounds (.40 S&W and .357 SIG) or 15 rounds (9mm Parabellum), plus one in the chamber.
Materials and Durability: The P229 shares the same alloy frame design with the P228, but spots a difference in its machined stainless steel slide, meant to handle the much stronger .40 S&W and .357 SIG rounds.

Personal Experience With the P229

Using the P229 offers a similar handling experience as the P228. However, swapping between different calibers brings about a noticeably different shooting experience. The more powerful .40 S&W and .357 SIG rounds generate more recoil, but the P229’s robust design and solid construction manage it well.

The only challenge faced with the P229 is its somewhat heavier weight due to the stainless steel slide, which can be a bit uncomfortable for extended carry periods.

The Pros and Cons of the P229

Pros:
- Caliber versatility adds flexibility for users.
- Robust construction made to handle more powerful rounds.
- Available and in production, making it easier to find parts and accessories.
Cons:
- Heavier than the P228, which may hamper comfort during extended carry periods.
- More substantial recoil due to more powerful ammunition.

In stark comparison, both the Sig Sauer P228 and P229 uphold an impressive lineup of features that make them stand out in the firearm industry. Each of them caters to varying user needs and preferences. Ultimately, the choice will hinge on your specific requirements for caliber, capacity, weight, and availability of the handgun and its accessories.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Why was the SiG P228 discontinued?

The SiG P228 was discontinued in 1999 because it was replaced by the SiG P229. The P228 was essentially an updated version of the earlier SiG P226, but the P229 offered further improvements in terms of ergonomics, versatility, and durability.

2. Will a SiG P228 fit in a P229 holster?

No, a SiG P228 will not fit in a P229 holster. While both pistols are similar in some aspects, they have different frames and dimensions. Therefore, it is important to use a holster specifically designed for each model to ensure a proper fit and functionality.

3. What is the difference between SiG P228 and P229?

The main difference between the SiG P228 and P229 lies in their design and construction. The P229 features a slightly shorter slide and barrel length compared to the P228. Additionally, the P229’s frame is made from an aluminum alloy, making it lighter and more resistant to corrosion compared to the P228’s stainless steel frame.

4. Is the M11 A1 a P228 or P229?

The M11 A1 is based on the SiG P228, which was originally selected by the U.S. Military for use by various branches under the designation “M11.” However, the M11 A1 incorporates a few modern upgrades and features from the P229. Therefore, it is often referred to as a hybrid between the two models.

5. What is the difference in grip size between the P228 and P229?

The grip size difference between the SiG P228 and P229 is minimal. The P229’s grip is slightly larger in circumference, allowing for a more ergonomic and comfortable hold. However, it is important to note that individual preferences can vary, so it is recommended to try both models before making a decision.

6. Can P228 magazines be used in a P229?

Unfortunately, P228 magazines cannot be used in a P229. While both pistol models share the same caliber and magazine capacity, their magazine designs are not interchangeable due to their different feed ramp angles. It is essential to use magazines specifically designed for the respective model.

7. Which pistol has better accuracy, the P228 or P229?

In terms of accuracy, both the P228 and P229 are highly reliable and accurate pistols. However, the P229 is often considered to have a slight advantage due to its improved ergonomics and shorter barrel length. Ultimately, the shooter’s skill level and familiarity with the firearm play a significant role in accuracy.

8. Can a P228 slide be converted to fit on a P229 frame?

No, it is not possible to convert a P228 slide to fit on a P229 frame. The two models have different slide and frame dimensions, which are not compatible with one another. Any modifications attempting such a conversion could negatively impact the function and safety of the firearm.

9. What are the differences between the P228 and P229 Legion series?

The P228 Legion and P229 Legion series share many similar features and upgrades. However, the P229 Legion features a slightly shorter slide, resulting in a compact overall size compared to the P228. Additionally, the Legion series incorporates enhanced ergonomics, a reduced reset trigger, and upgraded sights, among other refinements.

10. Which model, the P228 or P229, is better for concealed carry?

Both the SiG P228 and P229 are suitable for concealed carry depending on individual preferences. However, the P229’s smaller and more compact frame, combined with its slightly shorter barrel length, makes it a popular choice for those seeking ease of concealment without compromising firepower.