As an avid firearm enthusiast, my experience with Sig Sauer’s extensive line of handguns has been extensive. Today, we’ll delve into a comprehensive comparison of two of their most renowned models – the Sig P226 and the P228.
Comparison Table:
| Feature | Sig P226 | Sig P228 |
|---|---|---|
| Caliber | 9mm, .40 S&W, .357 SIG | 9mm |
| Barrel Length | 4.4 inches | 3.9 inches |
| Weight | 34 oz | 29.6 oz |
| Capacity | 15 rounds (9mm) | 13 rounds |
Sig P226
Features and Specifications
The Sig P226, an esteemed choice for many law enforcement agencies worldwide, is a full-sized, service-type pistol. Its versatility shines through the range of calibers it can accommodate – 9mm, .40 S&W, and .357 SIG. The barrel measures 4.4 inches, contributing to its total length of 7.7 inches. It also boasts a high ammunition capacity, holding 15 rounds of 9mm.
Personal Experience
One of the most impressive aspects of the P226 when I first used it was how amazingly balanced it felt in my hand. This is primarily due to the alloy frame and stainless steel slide that’s a hefty 34 oz. However, this weight could be a hurdle when it comes to carrying the piece for extended periods.
Pros
- High capacity (15 rounds of 9mm)
- Available in various calibers
- Durable construction
Cons
- Quite heavy, hence not ideal for extended carry
- Expensive
Sig P228
Features and Specifications
The Sig P228, meanwhile, is considered the compact cousin of the P226. Predominantly chambered for 9mm, the P228 sports a slightly smaller footprint with a 3.9-inch barrel and total length of 7.1 inches. It carries fewer rounds than the P226, holding 13 rounds.
Personal Experience
Coming from a P226, the P228 immediately felt lighter and more compact, at 29.6oz. To me, this made it much more comfortable for concealed carry. The reliable performance I had come to associate with Sig Sauer was consistent, and the smaller size did not compromise it.
Pros
- Lighter, and hence, more suitable for conceal carry
- Compact size without compromising performance
Cons
- Lower capacity (13 rounds)
- Only available in 9mm
In a nutshell, both the Sig P226 and P228 are exceptional firearms. They bring certain unique characteristics to the table, but your selection will ultimately depend on your specific needs. Whether it’s the full-service nature and high capacity of the P226 or the more compact frame of the P228 that appeals, rest assured, you can rely on these Sig Sauer models’ caliber of performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Why was the SIG P228 discontinued?
After being adopted by numerous law enforcement agencies and the military, the SIG P228 was eventually discontinued due to manufacturing costs and the introduction of the improved P229 model. The P228 was very similar to the P229, but the latter had a slightly more ergonomic grip design and could accommodate different calibers with the use of interchangeable slides.
Q: Why did the Navy Seals stop using the P226?
The Navy Seals transitioned from the SIG P226 to the Glock 19 due to various reasons. One of the primary factors was the Glock’s lighter weight, allowing for easier mobility during extended operations. Additionally, the Glock had a higher ammunition capacity, providing more rounds before reloading, and its simpler design made it easier to maintain and repair in the field.
Q: Which is better, the P226 or P229?
The choice between the SIG P226 and P229 largely depends on personal preference and the intended use. The P226 has a longer barrel, which can provide slightly better accuracy at longer distances. On the other hand, the P229 has a more compact size and a shorter barrel, making it more suitable for concealed carry purposes or for individuals with smaller hands. Both models offer exceptional reliability and are accurate firearms.
Q: When did Sig stop making the P228?
SIG Sauer stopped producing the P228 in 2017. However, it’s worth noting that the original P228 design lives on in the form of the M11-A1 and M11-A1 Compact, which are essentially updated versions of the P228 with some minor improvements.
Q: What are the main differences between the P226 and P228?
The main differences between the SIG P226 and P228 are the grip size and the overall dimensions. The P226 has a larger grip and a longer barrel, while the P228 has a more compact grip and a slightly shorter barrel. Additionally, the P228 generally holds two fewer rounds in the magazine compared to the P226, although this can vary depending on the magazine used.
Q: Can a P226 slide fit on a P228 frame?
Yes, a SIG P226 slide can fit on a P228 frame. The frames of both models are generally compatible, allowing for interchangeability to some extent. However, it’s crucial to ensure that all other components, such as magazines and springs, are compatible and properly fitted to ensure reliable functioning.
Q: Are the P226 and P228 both chambered in 9mm?
Both the SIG P226 and P228 are commonly chambered in 9mm. However, it’s important to note that these models can also be available in other calibers, such as .40 S&W and .357 SIG, depending on the specific variant or model version.
Q: Can the P226 and P228 be used for concealed carry?
While the SIG P226 and P228 are not the smallest handguns in terms of size, they can still be used for concealed carry. The P228, being slightly more compact, may be slightly easier to conceal than the P226, especially for individuals with smaller frames. Holsters specifically designed for these models can greatly aid in concealed carry comfort and effectiveness.
Q: Can the P226 and P228 accept aftermarket accessories?
Yes, both the SIG P226 and P228 have a wide range of aftermarket accessories available. This includes night sights, holsters, grips, extended magazines, and more. However, it’s always recommended to ensure that the accessories are designed to fit the specific model of your firearm to ensure proper compatibility and functionality.
Q: Can you upgrade the trigger on the P226 and P228?
Yes, the trigger on both the SIG P226 and P228 can be upgraded. There are numerous aftermarket trigger systems designed to improve the trigger pull, reduce trigger reset, and provide a more consistent trigger feel. However, it’s important to note that modifying the trigger may require the assistance of a qualified gunsmith to ensure safe installation and reliable performance.