As ardent fans of SIG Sauer firearms, it’s not easy settling for one when it comes to choosing a personal defense weapon or a reliable sidearm for shooting sports. Two models that tend to cause quite a stir in the discussion are the illustrious SIG P220 and the more contemporary P227. Both are revered for their accuracy, reliability, and robust construction among shooting enthusiasts. In this well-structured, in-depth comparison, we will dissect the features, pros, and cons of each to help you make an informed decision.
Comparison Table:
| SIG P220 | SIG P227 | |
|---|---|---|
| Caliber | .45 ACP | .45 ACP |
| Capacity | 8 + 1 | 10 + 1 |
| Barrel Length | 4.4″ | 4.4″ |
| Overall Length | 7.7″ | 7.7″ |
| Weight | 30.4 oz | 32 oz |
| Sights | Contrast Sights | Night Sights |
Dissecting the SIG P220
Born in the late 1970s, the SIG P220 is a semi-automatic pistol chambered in .45 ACP. It’s a favourite among both police and military personnel, as well as civilian owners looking for a reliable full-sized pistol.
The Best Things about the SIG P220
Accuracy:
The SIG P220 is widely known for its exceptional accuracy.
Reliability:
It has proven to be a durable and reliable firearm, and time has only bolstered its reputation.
Fit and Finish:
The P220 boasts impeccable construction with a solid, well-balanced feel, which is a typical hallmark of SIG Sauer products.
Challenges Faced When Using the SIG P220
Weight:
At 30.4 ounces, this isn’t the lightest pistol on the market, which some users may find cumbersome.
Sights:
The standard SIG P220 model comes with contrast sights, which are not as good in low-light environments as the night sights featured on the P227.
Pros and Cons of the SIG P220
Pros:
- Exceptional accuracy
- Highly reliable and durable
- Quality unique fit and finish
Cons:
- Quite heavy
- Contrast sights not optimal for low light conditions
Deep Dive into the SIG P227
The SIG P227 arrived on the scene as a bigger-capacity cousin to the P220. It offered the same .45 ACP chambering but provided consumers with a much-requested increase in capacity.
The Best Things About the SIG P227
High Capacity:
What sets the P227 apart is its increased capacity, which can be a key advantage in self-defense situations.
Night Sights:
Unlike the P220, the P227 comes standard with night sights, ensuring visibility under low-light conditions.
Feel and Handling:
Despite its larger capacity, the P227 still manages to maintain a comfortable handle and balance, showing no compromise in ‘SIG’ quality.
Challenges Faced When Using the SIG P227
Weight:
Similar to its predecessor, P227 is on the heavier side, weighing 2 ounces more than P220.
Price:
The enhanced features of the P227 reflect on its price tag, making it a slightly more expensive choice.
Pros and Cons of the SIG P227
Pros:
- Extended ammunition capacity
- Night sights for improved visibility
- Comfortable handling despite larger capacity
Cons:
- Weighs more than the P220
- More expensive than the P220
Takeaway
The SIG P220 and P227 are both remarkable weapons well worth their reputations. The P220 shines for its track record of reliability and accuracy. Conversely, the P227 ups the game with an increased capacity and standard night sights. However, your choice between the two ultimately depends on your unique needs, preferences and budget.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between P220 and P227?
The main difference between the SIG P220 and P227 handguns lies in their caliber and magazine capacity. The P220 fires the .45 ACP cartridge and typically has a single-stack magazine, holding up to 8 rounds. On the other hand, the P227 is chambered in .45 ACP as well but has a larger double-stack magazine, providing a higher capacity of up to 10 rounds. Another difference is that the P227 has a slightly wider grip frame to accommodate the wider magazine.
Did SIG discontinue the P227?
Yes, SIG Sauer discontinued the P227 pistol. It is no longer in production, and new units are no longer being manufactured. However, it may still be available for sale through various firearm retailers or in the second-hand market.
What happened to the SIG P227?
The SIG P227 was phased out by SIG Sauer and discontinued. The reasons behind discontinuing a firearm model can vary, including market demand, product focus, or the introduction of newer models. While the P227 may no longer be in production, users can still find support, accessories, and aftermarket parts due to its popularity during its release.
Did SIG discontinue the P220?
No, as of current information, SIG Sauer has not discontinued the P220. The P220 is still part of SIG’s product line and remains a popular choice among firearms enthusiasts and professionals alike, known for its reliability and accuracy.
What are some other notable differences between the P220 and P227?
In addition to the caliber and magazine capacity, one notable difference between the P220 and P227 is their grip design. The P220 typically features a more rounded and slimmer grip, suitable for those with smaller hands or who prefer a sleeker feel. On the other hand, the P227 has a wider grip with more aggressive texturing, providing a better grip for those with larger hands or those who prefer enhanced control.
Are the P220 and P227 compatible with the same accessories?
Most accessories designed for the P220 are not directly interchangeable with the P227 due to differences in their grip frames and magazine dimensions. However, certain accessories, such as holsters or certain sights, may be compatible with both models. It’s always best to check with the manufacturer or consult a knowledgeable firearms specialist to ensure proper compatibility.
What is the suggested use for the P220 and P227?
The SIG P220 and P227 are both semi-automatic pistols that excel in various roles depending on the shooter’s needs. The P220 is a reliable and accurate firearm often used for concealed carry, home defense, or as a duty weapon for law enforcement officers. The P227, with its increased magazine capacity, is typically favored for those seeking a higher capacity firearm as their choice for home defense or duty use.
What are the available finishes for the P220 and P227?
SIG Sauer offers the P220 and P227 in multiple finish options, including the traditional Nitron coated stainless steel slide, which provides excellent durability and corrosion resistance. Additionally, some models may also feature stainless steel frames or other variations in finishes, such as two-tone or custom Cerakote coatings. The availability of finishes may vary depending on the specific model and distributor.
Can the P220 magazines be used in the P227 and vice versa?
No, the P220 and P227 magazines are not interchangeable due to the differences in magazine dimensions and design. The P220 utilizes single-stack magazines designed specifically for the .45 ACP cartridge, whereas the P227 employs double-stack magazines to accommodate its higher capacity. It is crucial to use the appropriate magazines designed for each respective model.
Is the P220 or P227 considered better for accuracy?
Both the P220 and P227 pistols are renowned for their accuracy. However, individual shooting preferences and comfort can play a significant role in determining which firearm works best for each shooter. It is recommended to try out both models, assess their inherent characteristics, and determine which one provides better accuracy and shooting experience for you personally.